COMPOSITE MACRO ETF IMPLIED COST OF CAPITAL ESTIMATES

Earlier this year I used to publish a bi-weekly article using the "Implied Cost of Capital" model as an ETF relative value estimation tool. Unfortunately State Street began reporting obvious erroneous data points and eventually stopped providing certain fundamental data altogether. As a result I had to suspend publishing of my ICC estimates. 

Well thanks to YCharts.com and their excellent site I was able to find the requisite data needed to begin publishing my model estimates again. 

what is the "implied cost of capital (ICC)" model?

In accounting and finance the implied cost of equity capital (ICC)—defined as the internal rate of return that equates the current stock price to discounted expected future dividends—is an increasingly popular class of proxies for the expected rate of equity returns.
— CHARLES C. Y. WANG; an assistant professor of business administration in the Accounting and Management Unit at Harvard Business School

The basic concept of the ICC model is that it is a forward looking estimate of the implied earnings growth rate of an equity security that is calculated using a combination of book value of equity and earnings forecasts.

To see a more involved explanation of the previous model I used see here.  

In the past I used a Multi-Stage Residual Income Model. However, this time around I've decided to use a simpler Single-Stage Residual Income Model for these estimates. I chose this because I believe the additional complexity is not warranted given my purpose which I will elaborate on further.

The Single-Stage Residual Income Model as defined by the CFA Institute is the following:

source: CFA Institute

'V' is the stock price at time 0, 'B' is the book value of equity at time 0, 'ROE' is return on equity, 'g' is an assumed long term growth rate and 'r' is the cost of equity/capital. The ICC model essentially solves for 'r' given the other inputs. 

why use the implied cost of capital model?

There is ongoing debate regarding the ICC model's application and accuracy as a proxy for expected returns as quoted by Charles C. Y. Wang. As an investor/trader I'm less interested in the academic debate and more intrigued by the intuition behind the model and its practical application as a relative value tool. 

I use the ICC model as a relative value measure to identify analyst/institutional expectations and sentiment between different market sectors at a point in time. 

For this purpose I believe it provides great insight. 

 

category average icc estimates

Long term growth rate (g) is assumed to be 2.5% reflective of our low growth high debt economic environment. 

 

all etf icc estimates by category

 

z-Score icc estimates and cumulative returns comparison chart

The below plot gives visual representation of the ICC estimates. I z-scored both year-to-date cumulative returns and the ICC estimates so we can view them on the same scale. Examining this chart allows investors to quickly determine which market sectors are outperforming (underperforming) their respective Implied Cost of Capital Estimates. 

The extreme cases show where there are disconnects between the analyst community's forward earnings expectations and actual market performance. The plot is sorted left to right by ascending ICC estimates.

 Data Sources: YCharts.com, Yahoo Finance

Data Sources: YCharts.com, Yahoo Finance